Saturday, September 26, 2020

UFC: Weight classes make the P4P rankings redundant

Now in any combat sport it is important to have rankings, so that you know where people stand. However, as the UFC is made up of weight classes and has been for some time, I question not only the accuracy of the pound for pound list but also its existence in the first place.

Early days of the UFC Royce was king

When the UFC started way back in 1993, it was an open weight tournament involving several fights over one night to determine who was the Ultimate Fighter. It was way more like a cheesy 80’s martial arts movie than the legitimate sport that we are presented with today.

Most importantly in terms of what I am writing about initially the UFC was open weight, there were no weight classes. Royce Gracie was the king early on, using the now widely known Gracie Brazilian Jujitsu style to defeat opponents much larger than him.

In the early days of open weight tournaments Royce Gracie reigned supreme
In the early days of open weight tournaments Royce Gracie reigned supreme

The early UFC tournaments really served as an advertising platform for Gracie Jujitsu. It was a way of saying to the world (or the martial arts fans watching at the time) look at what we can do, this martial art will give you the skills to defeat someone larger that you.

The advert worked like a charm and now we see Gracie Jujitsu and other BJJ schools all over the world. While BJJ is a great martial art, make no mistake as well as being that it is a profit machine generating millions for those who are skilled enough not just on the mat but in marketing their schools.

Weight classes

Going back to my main point, BJJ tournaments around the world now use weight classes. This is because if you have 2 fighters of a similar skill set, and one is much larger. Despite what 80’s films and some martial arts will tell you, the larger fighter will win 9 times out of 10.

But what about Royce Gracie in the first UFC tournaments I hear you ask, well yes Royce is MMA royalty no doubt and he was very successful. However his success in the early tournaments was largely due to the fact that his opponents literally did not know what BJJ was, so they had no way of countering or stopping his submissions.

Fast forward to 2006 and it seemed that the sport and the competitors has been brought up to speed. By this time you had Matt Hughes as the king of the welterweight division. Matt Hughes had enough knowledge of submissions to stop Royce.

The result of this was the revelation that even BJJ is not going to save you against someone who knows what they are doing and has a size or strength advantage.

Hughes wasn’t necessarily an over sized opponent for Royce (in fact Royce was larger), however Hughes was way stronger, and the point I am making here is that Hughes had enough knowledge to stop the crafty Brazilian veteran and the result was a savage beating.

Catch weight of 175lbs Hughes vs Gracie was one of the worst mis matches in UFC history.
Catch weight of 175lbs Hughes vs Gracie was one of the worst mis matches in UFC history.

The above brings be back to my main point, if Matt Hughes in 2006 was able to destroy Royce like that and they were the same weight. Then what would a guy like Andre Arlovski have done to him? So unless they actually beat the bigger guy how can you have a pound for pound list where the smaller guys rank higher?

Current pound for pound ranking

The fact that the UFC has clear weight classes makes the pound for pound rankings meaningless. Look at the current pound for pound rankings; you have Henry Cejudo above Stipe Miocic. That is crazy, Stipe is the heavy weight champion walking around at 250lbs, Cejudo weighs 160lbs on his heaviest days.

That is not to say that Cejudo isn’t skilled, but to even insinuate that he would beat Stipe Miocic in a fight is just madness. Now people will counter and say if they were the same size he would win. No he wouldn’t, because a lot of things that Cejudo can do because of his speed and agility are down to the fact he is a smaller guy.

Make them both the same size and one of their skill sets will not transfer, Stipe wont be the same if he is shrunk and Henry won’t be the same if he is bigger. That means the pound for pound rankings are just a complete fantasy, and I do not really understand why they are required.

I don't care what the pound for pound rankings say a flyweight is just not beating a large heavy weight like Nganu
I don’t care what the pound for pound rankings say a flyweight is just not beating a large heavy weight like Nganu

If we’re now going to start heading into the realms of the fantasy where you can make someone much larger or much smaller just by snapping your fingers. Then what about if one of them could fly, and the other one had laser eyes?

Those are just a ridiculous as magically making someone larger or smaller with no change to their attributes, for that reason the list is antiquated, ridiculous and for me has no bearing on how the fighters really stack up against each other.

For me as great and skilled as the smaller weight classes are, they impress me so much and I enjoy watching them. I still hold the ancient boxing mentality that the heavyweight champion is the “baddest man on the planet”, and no amount of made up pound for pound rankings will change my opinion on that.

For news and views on MMA please check out our combat sports section and don’t forget to follow us on Twitter for more sporting updates and some great isolation quizzes to keep you occupied.

Alex Green
Long suffering New York Jets fan, avid MMA viewer, been watching it since people still thought Ken Shamrock was quite good.

Similar Articles

Comments

Latest

UFC: Munhoz vs Edgar not a Robbery

So the dust has settled on the Bantamweight debut of Frankie the answer Edgar and it was a very good night for...

UFC Fight Night 174; Shogun vs Nogueira the Last of a Dying Breed.

Mauricio Shogun Rua and Antonio Rogerio Nogueira need no introduction to older fans of the UFC. Both of these men are Pride...

UFC 251: How Masvidal can beat Usman

UFC 251: How Masvidal can Beat Usman. So UFC 251 fight island is finally here, and stepping into the...

MMA: The GOAT argument is ridiculous and I’m tired of hearing about it

Recently one Mr Conor McGregor took to Twitter with his opinions on who is the greatest MMA fighter of all time (GOAT),...

Could The New York Jets Draft Trevor Lawrence?

Trevor Lawrence is the biggest prospect coming out of college football, with many expecting him to go as the first overall pick...

Reviewing Week 2 Of The NFL

Week 2 is complete in the NFL. From the injuries to what felt like half of the league as well as the...

NFL Week 3 early value looks

After another eventful and slightly unpredictable NFL weekend, it’s time to start looking ahead to the NFL Week 3 matchup to see where...